Sun Kil Moon
Ghosts of the Great Highway

Reviewed by: Chris deMaagd
Reviewed on: 2004-02-12

Log In to Post Comments
Posted 02/12/2004 - 11:45:10 AM by ARomaker:
 This review is so off base, it's funny. Ghosts is one of the best CDs of 2003. What a joke.
Posted 02/12/2004 - 05:31:22 PM by jroarty:
 Please disregard this review. Ghosts is a beautiful cd, one of Kozelek's best, and I seriously question whether the reviewer even listened to it, or any of Kozelek's earlier music. Country rock? James Iha??? Red House Painters were only very occasionally loud, rarely (if ever) "bombastic," and rather than a departure from Kozelek's earlier work, Ghosts is a near-perfect summation of it. He's a Johnny one-note, sure, but so were Nick Drake and Leonard Cohen. Those are the people to whom Kozelek should be compared, not the fucking Eagles.
Posted 02/13/2004 - 01:13:52 PM by rvincentpeters:
 This album is excellent. This review is bunk. A 5 year old could write better than this fool.
Posted 02/14/2004 - 12:09:44 AM by IanMathers:
 If we disregard one opinion, we must disregard all of them.
Posted 02/14/2004 - 08:57:43 PM by ESeguy:
 This was actually a really beautiful record (I heard it this weekend).
Posted 02/24/2004 - 10:35:17 PM by abefroman:
 um, holy fuck. bad review, this disc is beautiful. dude missed the point, methinks.
Posted 05/01/2004 - 09:19:55 PM by sekaer:
 I just registered here in order to add my voice to the wtf about this review...this is one of the most off-base reviews I have EVER read. I am not a huge Kozelek fan but this record is easily one of the best of the year. What was this reviewer thinking? Also, it's just a TAD bitchy, doncha think?
Posted 06/30/2004 - 05:30:01 PM by morninghollow:
 Ok. this is the worst review i have EVER read. who is this guy?
Posted 02/17/2005 - 01:13:23 AM by kidloki:
 A year after the fact, but I'd just like to chime in and say this review is worthless. Consistently, seemingly deliberately wrong. Terrible writing, terrible criticism.
Posted 10/26/2006 - 11:16:59 AM by hammmd:
 this guy has no business reviewing albums...these types of totally off-base reviews are the reason Stylus has never gained the status as a trusted site for reviews, even though the site is generally pretty accurate. crap.