“There were broadly speaking two genres of concept album: those that were essentially thematically-linked song cycles such as The Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, which did not claim a storyline, and those that presented a narrative story that threaded the songs—such as The Who’s Tommy.” — from the Wikipedia entry on concept albums
I’ve never been big on concept albums. Though my emergence into contemporary music came through a rockist method—there was a point in time when NoFX was my favourite band, for goodness’ sake—I viewed concept albums as the worst of rock’s excesses, pretentious bloated crap that purports to tell a story, but often butchers it through either musical wanking (too much) or conceptual wanking (not enough).
So, I’m not sure how I came upon it but at some point I discovered, to my surprise, that sometimes bands don’t necessarily tell stories with concept albums. Instead, through repeated passages, lyrics, and conceptual motifs, they unify an idea or a style under the umbrella of one album. Sometimes, they don’t even really serve to unify ideas so much as provide a kind of structure to the album itself.
Over the next few weeks, my goal is to hopefully provide interesting examples of this method of turning the ordinary into a concept album. First up, the A-Frames’ Black Forest.
Everything about Black Forest’s packaging reveals the uniformity of ideas within, stark tones and clip-art cutouts and a small paragraph with a feeling of technology gone awry. It’s dark and uncomfortable, and just looking at it gives you an idea of its mood; a little research and the discovery that they’re a three-piece post-punk/noise rock band gives you a good foreshadowing of its sound.
The first time you hear the album’s main theme, it’s titled “Black Forest I.” Clocking in at a little over a minute, it’s an instrumental based on a tremendously menacing bassline, ominous drums, and abrasive, searing yet miles-distant guitar. Minimalists through and through, the A-Frames frequently capitalize on a sense of paranoia and fear induced through the Information Age, and “Black Forest I” sets the tone for the first half of the album splendidly.
Yet despite all of this, the track time betrays a sense of brevity. And making it instrumental? Okay, the music sounds intimidating, but considering how laser-precise they are, how threatening can they really be? Songs like “Death Train,” despite their horrifying subject, well, they’re almost fun.
“Black Forest II,” midway through the album, answers that question with “really Goddamn threatening.” Clunky, ugly guitar introduces the song, and the drums have taken on a more tribal quality. The bass remains steady, but it’s been kicked up, present and furious. Erin Sullivan, lead singer, begins to articulate on the theme: “Humanity is erased / Black forest left in its place.” They’re not singing about any death trains. “No organism left to grow / Black forest and fallout snow.” They’re talking about the End Of The World As We Know It. The music steps into a steady rhythm and “Black forest” becomes the band’s voodoo chant. Four beats and they’re gone, from the centerpiece aside back into the album proper.
And holy hell. The next six songs are abrasive, heavy, a steady decline into sloppiness and insanity; though the A-Frames have one of the tighter rhythm sections in noise-rock, they’re able to make everything come across as harsh and raw. By the plain terrifying “My Teacher,” they’re done toying with you. They’re out to actually scare you, and possibly knife you in the mind. And by “Negative,” there’s nothing resembling order left, just three and a half minutes of buzzsaws and fury.
Then “Black Forest III” kicks in. The same guitar that started “Black Forest II” enters, but it’s gone out of tune, deranged, driven mad. Sullivan’s singing, but there’s something wrong, fundementally wrong with it. The music is grinding and scraping up against itself, machine-like, churning out black smoke as the instruments quit caring. The final minute of the album is a rhythm section buried underneath incredibly loud, grating sonic death, humanity under a black forest of waste, technology, and paranoia. “Black forest,” they chant again, but now it’s turned from a zombie-like chant into something rife with malice.
If you meet “Black Forest III” at night, it will kill you. Plain and simple.
The A-Frames are noise rockers, so they’re likely used to the phrase “musical pranksters” by now. And with Black Forest, they use that to their advantage: they lull the listener in with promises of a heavy but non-threatening experience, and then they finish with an unhinged, chaotic declaration of humanity’s close-at-hand self-destruction. “No punks, no garage bands,” and they mean it, themselves included. The difference between them and us is, they’re laughing.
But they’re not kidding around.
[buy stuff here]


March 20th, 2006 at 11:05 am
[…] Variations On A Theme, Pt. 1 […]
March 20th, 2006 at 7:33 pm
Thank you for posting this! I really love this album.