PJ Harvey
White Chalk

Island
2007
C+
Reviewed by: Josh Love
Reviewed on: 2007-09-28



Posted 09/28/2007 - 10:14:18 AM by mvdu76:
 This is the kind of close-minded review I expect from Stylus, unfortunately. It's a haunting CD and one of her best.
 
Posted 09/28/2007 - 11:45:24 PM by vohpoh:
 Finally! Someone who gives this album the C+ it deserves. BO-RING!
 
Posted 10/01/2007 - 01:16:43 AM by slugabed:
 Considering the reviwer has favored Tim McGraw over PJ Harvey, I could really give two sh*ts what this person has to say.
 
Posted 10/02/2007 - 07:15:43 PM by Richie_A:
 First 6 or 7 songs are great, it does start to tail off at a certain point and ends up feeling sort of insubstantial. Not one of her best but it's an interesting little departure. The review sucks for basically saying that she should stick to giving us what we're used to hearing from her over and over again, though.
 
Posted 10/03/2007 - 09:40:25 AM by florenz6:
 Re: Richie_A: This has been my experience, too. this could have been exactly my comment, every sentence, funny! But to come to a final conclusion, I should listen to it two more times. Might be, the second half would then reveal its possible secrets. (Sometimes our ears are not in first class form, and comments come too fast..) The song "When Under Ether" is awesome!